• Arshad M Malik
  • Asad Khan
  • Atif Jawaid
  • Abdul Aziz Laghari
  • K. Altaf Hussain Talpur


Background: The groin hernia repair is one of the common operations in general surgery. The optimumrepair method is under debate and the best mode of repair is yet to be decided. This study is conducted tocompare the results of open non-mesh (Modified Bassini’s) and Lichtenstein’s mesh repair of primaryinguinal hernia in terms of recurrence, postoperative complications and quality of life in the long term.Methods: This retrospective comparative analytical study includes 840 patients of which 40 patients wereexcluded from the study due to various reasons. The remaining 800 patients with unilateral primaryinguinal hernia, above 16 years of age, operated during January 2000 to December 2007 in a teachinghospital are included in the study. Of the total number, 392 patients (49%) underwent Lichtenstein meshrepair, while remaining 408 patients (51%) were operated by modified Bassini’s suture technique. Followup was conducted 1, 5, 8 and 15 days; 1, 2, 6, 24 and 36 months. Results: The recurrence rate andpostoperative pain were significantly low in Lichtenstein mesh repair compared to open non-mesh repairby modified Bassini’s technique (p<0.001). Recurrence occurred in 8 (2.0%) out of 392 patients thosewith Lichtenstein mesh repair. On the other hand 29 (7.1%) patients with Bassini’s repair reportedrecurrence within 3 years time. Conclusion: Mesh repair of inguinal hernia is much superior to non-meshrepair in terms of recurrence and postoperative chronic pain.Keywords: Inguinal hernia, open repair, Lichtenstein repair, morbidity, recurrence


Paul A, Troidl H, Williams JL, Rixen D, Langen R. Randomized

trial of modified Bassini versus Shouldice inguinal hernia repair.

The cologne Hernia study group. Br J Surg 1994;81:1531–4.

Beets GL, Oosterhuis KJ, Go PM, Baeten CG, Kootstra G. Long

term follow up (10–15 years) of a randomized controlled trial

comparing Bassini-stetten, shouldice and high ligation with

narrowing of internal ring for primary inguinal hernia repair. J

Am Coll Surg 1997;185:352–7.

Simon MP, Kleijnen J, Van Geldere D, Hoitsma HF, Obertop H,

Role of Shouldice technique in inguinal hernia repair; a

systematic review of controlled trials and a meta-analysis. Br J

Surg 1996;83:734–8.

Lichtenstein IL, Schulman AG. Ambulatory outpatient hernia

surgery. Including a new concept: Introducing tension–free

repair. Int Surg 1986;71:1–4.

Bendavid R. The need for mesh. In Bendavir R. ed. Prosthesis

and abdominal wall hernias. Austin, Texas: RG Lendas,


Vrijland WW, van den Tol MP, Luijendijk RW, Hop

WC, Busschbach JJ, de Lange DC, et al. Randomized clinical

trial of non-mesh versus mesh repair of primary inguinal hernia.

Br J Surg 2002;.89(3):293–7.

Gianelta E, Cuneo S, Vitale B, Camerini G, Marini P, Stella M.

Anterior tension free repair of recurrent inguinal hernia under

local anesthesia: a 7 year experience in a teaching hospital. Ann

Surg 2000;231:132–6.

Holzheimer RG. Low recurrence rate in hernia repair-results in

patients with open mesh repair of primary inguinal hernia.

Eur J Med Res 2007;31:12(1):1–5.

Grant AM, EU Hernia trialist collaboration. Open mesh versus

non-mesh repair of groin hernias: Meta analysis of randomized

trials based on individual patient data. Fernia 2002;6(3):130–6.

Collaboration EH. Mesh compared with non-mesh methods of

open groin hernia repair. Systematic review of randomized

control trials. Br J Surg 2000;87:854–9.

Barth RJ Jr, Burchard KW, Tostenson A, Sutton JE Jr, Collachio

TA, Henriques HF et al. Short term outcome after mesh or

Shouldice herniorrhaphy: a randomized, prospective study.

Surgery 1998;123:121–6.

Liem MS, Halsema JA, van der Graaf Y, Schrijvers AJ, van

Vroonhoven TJ. Cost-effectiveness of extraperitoneal

laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: a randomized comparison

with conventional herniorrhaphy. Coala trial group. Ann Surg


Nathan JD, Pappas TN. Inguinal hernis: an old condition with

new solutions. Ann Surg 2003;238(6 suppl):S148–57.

McCormack K, Scott NW, Go PM, Ross S, Grant AM, EU

Hernia Trialist Colloboration. Cochrane Database Syst Rev


Hair A, Duffy K, McLean J, Talor S, Smith H, Walker A et al.

Groin hernia repair in Scotland. BJS 2000;87:1722–6.

Vale L, Grant A, Mc Cormac, Scott NW, EU Hernia Trialist

collaboration. Cost effectiveness of alternative methods of

surgical repair of inguinal hernia. Int J Technol Assess Health

Care 2004;20(2):192–200.

Milic DJ, Pejic MA. Tension free procedures in the

surgical treatment of groin hernias. Spr Arh Cleok Lek


Scott NW, McCormac K, Graham P, Go PM, Ross SJ, Grant

AM. Open mesh versus non-mesh for repair of femoral and

inguinal hernia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev


Van Veen RN, Wijsmuller AR, Vrijland WW, Hop WC, Lange

JF, Jeekel J. Long term follow up of a randomized clinical trial of

J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad 2009;21(1)


non-mesh versus mesh repair of primary inguinal hernia. Br J

Surg 2007;94:506–10.

Nordin P, Bartelmess P.Jansson C, Svensson C, Edlund

G.Randomized trial of Lichtenstein versus shouldice hernia

repair in general surgical practice. Br J Surg 2002;89:45–9.

Bisgaard T, Bay-Nielson M, Christensen IJ, Kehlet H. Risk of

recurrence 5 years or more after primary Lichtenstein mesh and

sutured inguinal hernia repair. Br J Surg 2007;94:1038–40.

Butters M, Redecke J, Koninger J. Long term results of

randomized clinical trial of Shouldice, Lichtenstein and

transabdominal preperitoneal hernia repairs. Br J Surg


Solorzano CC, Minter RM, Childers TC, Kilkenny JW 3rd,

Vauthey JN. Prospective evaluation of the giant prosthetic

reinforcement of the visceral sac for recurrent and complex

bilateral inguinal hernias. Am J Surg 1999;177:19–22.

Wright D, Patterson C, Scott N, Hair A, O’Dwyer PJ. Five year

follow up of patients undergoing laparoscopic or open groin

hernia repair. Arandomized control trial. Ann Surg


Calleson T, Bech K, Kehlet H, Prospective study of chronic pain

after groin hernia repair. Br J Surg 1999,86:1528–31.

Courtney CA, Duffy K, Serpell MG, O’Dwyer PJ. Outcome of

patients with severe chronic pain following repair of groin hernia.

Br J Surg 2002; 89:1310–4.